Paper Drinking Straws: Benefits, Best Uses & Disadvantages

Paper straws show up everywhere now, from coffee shops to birthday parties, usually with a quiet assumption attached: paper equals good, plastic equals bad. The reality is more interesting. Paper straws do some things genuinely well and other things poorly, and knowing the difference saves you money and a few soggy sips. We have gone through more boxes of them than we can count, so here is the practical rundown of what paper straws are good for, where they fall short, and when it makes more sense to sip reusably instead.

Our top picks

Reusably is reader-supported; the links below are affiliate links, so we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

• For events and parties — bulk biodegradable paper straws. When you need a hundred straws for one afternoon, a compostable paper box is the sensible call.
• For everyday drinks — an insulated tumbler with a silicone straw. If you drink from the same cup daily, one reusable setup ends the paper-straw refill cycle for good.
• For travel — a stainless steel straw set with a case. Never soggy, tucks in a bag, lasts years.

What are paper straws made of?

Most paper straws are wound from a few layers of food-grade paper, then bonded with a thin coating so they hold up in liquid. That coating is the whole ballgame. It is what keeps the straw from turning to mush in the first minute, and it is also where the environmental questions creep in, because not every coating is created equal. The paper itself is usually plant-based and often sourced from responsibly managed forests, which is the part that makes paper feel like the greener choice.

Paper straws at a glance

The benefits of paper straws

Paper straws earn their popularity for real reasons, especially compared with conventional plastic:

• They break down quickly. A 2024 study found that biodegradable straws degrade in roughly 8 to 20 months in coastal seawater, according to the American Chemical Society, far faster than plastic, which NOAA notes can persist for an uncertain but very long time.
• They start from a renewable material. Paper comes from trees and plant fiber rather than petroleum, so the raw material can be regrown and, done right, responsibly harvested.
• No microplastics. Paper does not shed the tiny plastic fragments that a weathering plastic straw leaves behind in soil and water.
• They are event-friendly. For a party, a wedding, or a busy cafe, paper is cheap enough to hand out by the hundred and compostable if the coating allows.

What paper straws are best for

Paper straws shine in a narrow lane, and they are great inside it. Reach for them with cold, thin drinks you will finish fairly quickly, think water, soda, iced tea, lemonade, or a cocktail at a gathering. They are also a solid pick anytime a reusable is not practical, like serving a crowd. Where they struggle is anything hot, thick, or slow: coffee, milkshakes, and drinks you nurse for an hour will soften the straw before you reach the bottom.

The disadvantages of paper straws

This is where we have to be honest, because paper straws are not the flawless swap they are marketed as:

• They get soggy. Paper is porous, so it softens and can collapse, especially in hot or acidic drinks. Nurse a drink and you may be chewing cardboard by the end.
• Coatings can carry PFAS. A 2023 peer-reviewed study in Food Additives & Contaminants found PFAS “forever chemicals” in most paper straws tested, more often than in plastic ones. We covered this in depth in are paper straws toxic? The short version: coatings vary a lot by brand, and the “forever” part defeats the purpose of going biodegradable.
• They are single-use. Unlike a real reusable straw, paper is designed for one drink. Try to rinse and reuse it and the coating and fibers give out fast.
• They cost more per straw. Paper runs several times the price of plastic per unit and weighs more to ship.
• Recycling is hit or miss. The coating and small size mean many programs will not take them, so composting is often the only good end-of-life route, and only for uncoated types.

If those trade-offs bug you, they should. It is exactly why many people skip the disposable question entirely and move to bamboo, glass, steel, or silicone. Our paper vs plastic straw breakdown weighs both disposables side by side, and our look at bamboo straw benefits covers the most natural reusable option.

Frequently asked questions

Are paper straws reusable?

No. Paper straws are designed for a single use. The food-safe coating and the paper fibers begin to break down once wet, so rinsing and reusing one leads to a soggy, unreliable straw. If you want to reuse, choose glass, stainless steel, silicone, or bamboo instead.

Are paper straws a healthier option than plastic?

Not necessarily. Paper straws avoid BPA and phthalates, but many are coated with PFAS “forever chemicals,” which a 2023 study detected in the majority of paper straws tested. So paper is not automatically the cleaner choice, and it varies by brand.

How long do paper straws last in a drink?

Usually somewhere between about 30 minutes and a couple of hours, depending on the brand, the coating, and the drink. Hot and acidic beverages soften them fastest, while a cold water or soda buys you the most time.

Are paper straws recyclable or compostable?

Compostable if they are uncoated, but the coatings that keep paper straws intact often make them non-recyclable and slow to compost. Check your local guidance, and treat composting an uncoated straw as the best realistic option.

Are paper straws better for the environment than plastic?

On breakdown time, yes, roughly 8 to 20 months versus decades or more for plastic, and paper does not create microplastics. But paper is still single-use and may carry PFAS coatings, so a reusable straw remains the most eco-friendly choice overall.

The bottom line

Paper straws are a reasonable choice for cold, quick drinks and for events where reusables are not practical, and they clearly beat plastic on how fast they disappear. But they go soggy, they can carry chemical coatings, and they are still something you throw away. For your everyday drink, doing away with disposable is the simpler, cheaper path. Keep a box of compostable paper straws for guests, and let a reusable handle the rest. Not sure how to keep a reusable clean? Here is how to clean reusable straws the easy way.